Federal Court Gives Green Light To Wild Horse Lawsuit

District Judge Rejects Interior Dept. Motion to Dismiss Case

Sacramento, Calif. (April 20, 2011) – In a precedent-setting decision, issued today in the United States District Court, Eastern District of California, Judge Morrison C. England, Jr. rejected the U.S. Department of Interior’s motion to dismiss a lawsuit challenging the roundup and removal of nearly 1,579 wild horses and 159 burros from the Twin Peaks Herd Management Area (HMA) in northeastern California last year.

Judge England also ruled that the plaintiffs – animal protection organization In Defense of Animals (IDA), ecologist Chad Hanson, Ph.D., wild horse sanctuary founder Barbara Clarke, DreamCatcher Wild Horse and Burro Sanctuary, local resident and wild horse enthusiast Linda Hay – have standing to challenge the action and that the case is not moot, despite the fact that the roundup has already taken place. In past wild horse roundup litigation, courts have dismissed claims as moot because the roundups had already concluded, never ruling on the merits on the case.

However, In Defense of Animals et al. vs. Interior Department et al., headed by pro bono legal counsel Rachel Fazio, outlines specific remedies and the ongoing harm plaintiffs suffer from Twin Peaks mustangs being held in captivity in government long-term holding facilities – facilities that the plaintiffs allege are illegal. Fazio argued in her briefs that the case was not moot, in part because the Interior Department could return captured horses to the range.

“The American Mustang is a native wildlife species; few people realize that the western United States is actually the evolutionary birthplace of the horse,” said Rachel Fazio, legal counsel for plaintiffs. “This suit seeks to ensure that, in accordance with the laws of Congress, this majestic species is protected as wild and free-roaming, safe from illegal interference by the BLM and immune to the pressures of the livestock industry and other commercial interests that wish to exploit our public lands.”

Plaintiffs in the litigation include Barbara Clarke, wild horse expert and director of the 2,000-acre DreamCatcher Wild Horse and Burro Sanctuary in Northeastern California, DreamCatcher Wild Horse and Burro Sanctuary, ecologist Dr. Chad Hanson, Linda Hay, a local resident who has visited and enjoyed the Twin Peaks horses for the past thirty years, and animal protection organization In Defense of Animals.

“We may finally have a court address the merits of a case challenging wild horse roundups and not dismiss it on technicalities,” said Eric Kleiman, Research Director for In Defense of Animals. “This is a groundbreaking legal decision that could lead to America’s wild horses finally having their day in court.”

In addition, the plaintiffs have appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals Judge England’s denial last year of a preliminary injunction to halt the Twin Peaks roundup. The remedy of returning horses to the range was also a critical issue of discussion at a hearing before the Ninth Circuit in San Francisco earlier this year.

Meanwhile, Twin Peaks horses have been scattered across the country at Interior Department’s Bureau of Land Management (BLM) holding facilities, and untold numbers have perished while in captivity.

Plaintiffs have revisited the Twin Peaks area and report difficulty locating wild horses to view in the aftermath of the roundup.

Between August and September 2010 – the hottest months of the year – the BLM removed 1,579 wild horses and 159 burros from the HMA. The roundup was a devastating blow to California’s wild horse and burro population, removing more than one-third of California’s entire mustang and burro population which is estimated to be only approximately 5,000 throughout the entire state. The Twin Peaks HMA encompasses 798,000 acres of public land, yet the BLM allows just 448 to 758 wild horses and 72 to 116 burros to reside in the area. Meanwhile, the agency authorizes up to four times more cattle and nearly seven times more sheep to graze this federally-designated wild horse and burro habitat.

Wild horses comprise a small fraction of grazing animals on public lands, where they are outnumbered by livestock nearly 50 to 1. The BLM has recently increased cattle grazing allotments in areas where wild horses are being removed. Currently the BLM manages more than 245 million acres of public lands of which cattle grazing is allowed on 160 million acres; wild horses are only allowed on 26.6 million acres this land, which must be shared with cattle. The Obama Administration has accelerated the removal of wild horses and burros from public lands in the past year, while Congress just last week approved funding for yet more BLM roundups beginning this July. There are currently more than 36,000 wild horses warehoused in government holding facilities and only 33,000 wild horses free on the range.

In Defense of Animals is an international animal protection organization located in San Rafael, Calif. dedicated to protecting animals’ rights, welfare, and habitat through education, outreach, and our hands-on rescue facilities in Mumbai, India, Cameroon, Africa, and rural Mississippi. For more information, visit www.idausa.org.


Eric Kleiman, In Defense of Animals, (717) 939-3231
Rachel Fazio, Esq., (530) 273-9290

In Defense of Animals is an international animal protection organization located in San Rafael, Calif. dedicated to protecting animals' rights, welfare, and habitat through education, outreach, and our hands-on rescue facilities in Mumbai, India, Cameroon, Africa, and rural Mississippi. _________________________________________________________________________________

IN DEFENSE OF ANIMALS • 3010 KERNER BLVD. • SAN RAFAEL, CA 94901 • 415-448-0048

9 Comments on “Federal Court Gives Green Light To Wild Horse Lawsuit”

  • arlene orlando wrote on 26 April, 2011, 9:56

    Finall a rey of sunshine for the American Wild Mustangs , God Bless Morrison c , Edmond for his insight…………………

  • Anne wrote on 6 June, 2011, 3:06

    I hope IDA will be able to stop any future roundups…right on IDA ! ! ! thnx!

  • iphone 5 casing wrote on 10 January, 2013, 19:36

    According to Dr. In portrait mode you can see facing pages, much
    like a real book. Aluminum Cases: Aluminum cases are literally the heavy weights when it
    comes to mobile protection.

  • Eunice wrote on 1 October, 2014, 1:55

    naturally like your web site however you have to check
    the spelling on quite a few of your posts. Several
    of them are rife with spelling issues and I in finding it very troublesome to inform
    the reality however I will surely come again again.

  • issuu.com wrote on 10 October, 2014, 20:01

    Thank you for some other informative website. Where ese may
    just I get that type of information written in such a perfect way?
    I have a undertaking hat I’m simply now opeerating on, and I’ve
    been att the glance out for such information.

  • weight loss surgery wrote on 13 October, 2014, 16:50

    I am in fact thankful to the holder of this website
    who has shared this fantastic article at at this time.

  • Communication Development wrote on 4 January, 2015, 8:13

    Magnificent website. Lots of helpfuyl info here. I’m sending it to
    several pals ans additionally sharing in delicious. And of course,
    thank you in your sweat!

  • improve your seo wrote on 13 December, 2015, 20:31

    I am in fact grateful to the holder of this web site who has shared this fantastic
    paragraph at here.


  1. Local seo scarborough

Write a Comment

Gravatars are small images that can show your personality. You can get your gravatar for free today!

Copyright © 2016 IDA News.